Commenting vs Questioning | EYFS

EYFS definition

Commenting and questioning are two ways adults contribute to children’s communication. Commenting offers words or observations; questioning invites a response. In the EYFS, both can support language and thinking when adults respond to the child and leave space for their contribution.

What is the difference?

A comment might describe an action, share an idea or add language to something the child has noticed. A question might find out what the child means, invite an explanation or help them consider a possibility.

The distinction concerns what the adult’s contribution asks of the child. “The sand is sticking together” offers an observation. “What could we make with it?” invites the child to contribute an idea.

What might this look like in practice?

A toddler points to a passing lorry. An adult says, “A big lorry,” then pauses for a sound, gesture or word. Later, a child building a road explains where it leads after an adult asks, “Where will your road go?”

During a familiar story, a practitioner might comment on a character’s expression, listen to the children’s ideas and ask a follow-up question connected to what they say.

Choosing a useful response

Questions can open a conversation, while a run of questions may leave less room for the child’s own direction. Comments also need pauses; continuous narration can become difficult to follow.

The balance can vary with the child, purpose and moment. Waiting, watching and accepting communication through actions, signs or pictures can be as relevant as choosing the next words.

Further Guidance | Related Documents

Explore resources connected with this term. Each card identifies the resource’s intended age group and access type.

Highlighted resource

Find practical resources for your setting

Start with an age gateway

Useful routes into practice

Explore more of the site